Excommunication
Excommunication is a true principle included in the
gospel of Jesus Christ. Although it may not seem immediately intuitive to say
this, excommunication is not a bad thing, at least not when we understand it as
more than simply an unfeeling effort to deprive someone of his or her
membership. The Lord Himself teaches it and abides by it. He also revealed it
to His prophets in every dispensation and expected them to abide by it. There
are sound reasons for and specific blessings that stem from excommunication.
Excommunication
Taught in Every Dispensation
The principle of excommunication has been taught in
every dispensation throughout scriptural history. Jehovah told Moses, “Whosoever
hath sinned against me, him will I blot out of my book” (Exodus 32:33). During
His mortal ministry, the Savior taught that those who “become a
transgressor…shall be cut off” (JST Mark 9:42). The apostle Paul explained that
the Corinthian Saints were to “put away from among [themselves] that wicked
person” (1 Corinthians 5:13).
When Alma first encountered sin and rebellion in
the Church, the Lord told him, “whosoever will not repent of his sins the same
shall not be numbered among my people,” then added, “and this shall be observed
from this time forward” (Mosiah 26:32). Two to three decades later, Alma’s son
found that within the Church “the hearts of many were hardened, and their names
were blotted out” while at the same time “many withdrew themselves from among”
the Church (Alma 1:24).
When the Savior ministered among the people of the
American continent, he spoke of those who would not repent. He counseled them
to “not cast him out from among you, but ye shall minister unto him and shall
pray for him unto the Father” nevertheless “if he repent not he shall not be
number among my people, that he may not destroy my people” (3 Nephi 18:30-31).
Moroni recorded that the members in his day “were strict to observe that there
should be no iniquity among them; and whoso was found to commit iniquity, and
three witnesses of the church did condemn them before the elders, and if they
repented not, and confessed not, their names were blotted out, and they were
not numbered among the people of Christ” (Moroni 6:7).
In our dispensation, at least four times in the
Doctrine and Covenants the Lord teaches the principle of excommunication. A
declaration of our beliefs, canonized by a unanimous vote on August 17, 1835
states, “We believe that all religious societies have a right to deal with
their members for disorderly conduct” and can “excommunicate them from their
society, and withdraw from them their fellowship” (Doctrine and Covenants
134:10). While we must acknowledge that excommunication is an unpleasant and unhappy
occasion, it is nonetheless a necessary principle of the gospel.
It is abundantly clear that those circumstances
that brought about a need for excommunication in dispensations past are prevalent
in the Church today.
Something that is not often acknowledged by people
who are excommunicated, or by those who support them, is the persecution they
inflict on the faithful members of the Church. In Alma’s day, it “was a great
trial to those that did stand fast in the faith” and they, unfortunately, had
to bear “with patience the persecution which [was] heaped upon” the faithful
(Alma 1:25). Joseph Smith explained, “Renegade ‘Mormon’ dissenters are running
through the world and spreading various foul and libelous reports against us,
thinking thereby to gain the friendship of the world” (Teachings of Presidents of the Church: Joseph Smith, “Beware the
Bitter Fruits of Apostasy,” p. 322). Members today will experience the same
circumstances and have the same need to bear with patience the persecution.
Sound Reasons
for Excommunication
At first glance, it may seem contrary to the gospel
of Jesus Christ to excommunicate a member. It may even appear as an unloving
practice. After all, we are encouraged to invite everyone to come unto Christ, become
His disciple, and join His Church. After doing that, why would we want to take
away a person’s membership? In reality, excommunication is a principle of the
gospel that shows God’s love for all of His children. It is an indication to
the one excommunicated that his or her behavior has gone beyond the bounds of what
is appropriate for those who want to be disciples of Jesus Christ and faithful
members of His Church. It is a way to admonish us according to our sins when we
are unwilling to repent (see Mosiah 26:39). It is, or should be, an alarming
wake-up call to the person, and to those who sympathize with the person, that his
or her behavior as a member is seriously out of order. Excommunication can be
seen as a last resort to save us from the ingeniously deceptive grasps of the
adversary and the eternal consequences of a rebellious disposition.
The Lord has a standard He wants His disciples to
live up to. He calls them laws or commandments. In modern revelation he defines
commandments as directions, saying, “I give unto you a new commandment, that
you may understand my will concerning you; Or, in other words, I give unto you
directions how you may act before me, that it may turn to you for your
salvation” (Doctrine and Covenants 82:8–9). While He allows for weaknesses and
mistakes as we learn to follow His directions, He has limits to the things we
can do. Brigham Young said it best when he taught, “It is given to us, as
agents, to choose or refuse…but we are agents within limits; if it were not so
there would be no law” (Discourses of
Brigham Young, p. 224). Excommunication does not usually happen unless a
person has been warned of their behavior and taught what is expected.
In the Old Testament, Jehovah said he would “blot
out” the names of those who sinned against Him. The phrase “blot out” comes
from the Hebrew word “machah” which carries the connotation of separating
someone who has develope a “warlike” spirit (see Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, “machah,” H4229).
This is usually the case with those who apostatize. They tend toward a
“warlike” attitude both before and after they have been excommunicated. The
Prophet Joseph Smith put it this way, “Those who have associated with us and
made the greatest professions of friendship, have frequently been our greatest
enemies and our most determined foes; if they became unpopular, if their
interest or dignity was touched, or if they were detected in their iniquity” (Teachings of Presidents of the Church:
Joseph Smith, “Beware the Bitter Fruits of Apostasy,” p. 322).
Blessings
that Stem from Excommunication
There are at least four specific blessings that
result from excommunication. First, it is a clear signal to people that they
have a solemn need to repent. It provides an opportunity for sinners to transform
their behavior to more fully resemble the directions, laws, and principles
taught in the gospel of Jesus Christ.
Second, excommunication protects the innocent and
unwary. It provides a way for other members to escape deception. Those who may
have sympathized with or who perhaps even began to follow the teachings and
behaviors of the one excommunicated can now see clearly to avoid taking an
erroneous path themselves.
Third, excommunication protects the integrity of
the Church. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has a good name and
reputation. If it is to be attractive to those who do not belong to it, it must
be kept clean and worthy of that name and reputation. On more than one occasion
the Lord declared , “Behold, mine house is a house of order…and not a house of
confusion” (Doctrine and Covenants 132:8; 88:119; 109:8). The Prophet Joseph Smith once said, "So long as unrighteous acts are suffered in the Church, it cannot be sanctified, neither can Zion be redeemed" (Teachings of Presidents of the Church: Joseph Smith, p. 187).
Fourth, when Church leaders fulfill their
responsibility to keep the Church clean, peace and prosperity among Church
membership are realized. Once Alma followed the directions given him by the
Lord to excommunicate the unrepentant, he was able to “regulate all the affairs
of the church; and they began again to have peace and to prosper exceedingly in
the affairs of the church, walking circumspectly before God, receiving many,
and baptizing many” (Mosiah 26:37).
We can experience the same blessings in our day as
Church leaders fulfill the difficult, yet necessary, responsibility to regulate
the affairs of the Church, which sometimes involves excommunication.